Review Criteria

Please review the following criteria carefully to proceed. Review of the Performance Complaint Criteria drop-down is required to proceed to the next step.

  1. Step 1
  2. Step 2
  3. Step 3
Performance Complaint Criteria

If you have a supplier of components or materials or a provider of manufacturing processes that is certified to IATF 16949 and the supplier has demonstrated through its actions and performance that it is not meeting requirements due to failures or gaps attributable to specific clauses in the IATF 16949 standard, then it might be appropriate to submit a Performance Complaint against the supplier’s IATF 16949 QMS certification.

Note: a Performance Complaint is only to be raised after all the standard internal customer processes to address supplier QMS concerns related to quality, delivery or process compliance issues have been completed and the complaint has been escalated to and approved by leadership for submission.

Two major categories of a performance issue leading to the potential for a Performance Complaint are:

  • Chronic, systemic evidence that the organization is not meeting the customer’s quality or delivery performance requirements resulting from:a) A QMS inadequate to meet customer’s requirements, orb) The organization’s nonconformance to its own QMS processes
  • Chronic, systemic evidence of the organization not meeting the customer’s quality or delivery process requirements

Note: The result of the violation of the customer-required process does not always directly impact past or current product performance to quality or delivery requirements

Customer quality and delivery performance requirements are typically defined in their supplier quality / delivery portals and/or scorecard systems. Additional clarification of IATF OEM customer performance scoring might be available through the customer’s IATF Quick Reference Guide, if available, through https://www.iatfglobaloversight.org/oem-requirements/quick-reference-guides/

Customer process requirements are typically defined through the Customer Requirements or Customer Specific Requirements. IATF OEM CSRs are available through https://www.iatfglobaloversight.org/oem-requirements/customer-specific-requirements/.

Note: if the complainant is an IATF OEM (see https://www.iatfglobaloversight.org/about-iatf/) please contact your IATF OEM representative regarding the submission of a Performance Complaint.

Examples of Acceptable/Unacceptable Performance Complaints for Quality or Delivery Performance Levels

Acceptable Performance Complaint Examples for Quality or Delivery Performance Levels:

Although each customer ultimately determines what constitutes a concern, examples of certified site quality or delivery performance levels resulting in a Performance Complaint include, but are not limited to:

Generic examples

  • Multiple repeat identical issues where the supplier’s corrective actions have proven to be ineffective
  • Sustained poor performance resulting in production (and/or service) quality or delivery performance score below the customer’s required minimum level
  • Ineffective response within the supplier’s corrective action process, including escalation levels

Specific examples from IATF OEMs

  • Instances within the last six months of production quality concerns that are included in the quality rating for the certified site
  • 2 or more instances in the last six months of customer plant operations being interrupted (e.g., assembly plant line stoppages or stop shipments / yard holds) due to nonconforming product from the certified site
  • A recent Government mandated safety recall of vehicles sold to end customers due to product from the certified site within the last six months (determined to be supplier responsible)

Note: each customer can specify the required metrics, targets and time periods to trigger a concern for the consideration of issuing a Performance Complaint, the list above only contains possible examples

Unacceptable Performance Complaint Examples for Quality or Delivery Performance Levels:

Examples of issues or concerns that should NOT be filed as an performance complaint include, but are not limited to:

  • Quality issues from 2 years ago (or beyond the customer stated performance period), with no repeated concerns
  • Single instance of a product quality of delivery issue not repeated
  • Single instance of an issue from immature data (not yet confirmed per the regular quality reject process)
  • Poor score from a trial metric at the customer, which is not impacting the overall official performance score
  • Commercial issue due to a pricing dispute between the certified organization and the customer
  • Customer Supplier Quality or delivery Personnel bundling all delivery issues into Performance Complaints due to lack of customer resources
  • Quality issues not escalated to the organization’s IATF QMS leadership and approved for submission as a Performance Complaint. Not following the internal process to get approval for filing the complaint.
  • Issue agreed by the customer not to be the responsibility of the certified site (e.g., responsibility of customer design, supplier to the certified site, etc.)
  • Insufficient capacity to make product quantities beyond that approved by the customer in capacity demonstration runs
  • Not meeting quality levels beyond that specified in the contract
  • Concern not attributable to any clause in the IATF standard such as a legal dispute with the supplier
Examples of Acceptable/Unacceptable Performance Complaints for Process Complaint Concerns

Acceptable Performance Complaint Examples for Process Complaint Concerns:

Although each customer ultimately determines what constitutes a concern qualifying for a Performance Complaint, examples of certified site process compliance concerns resulting in a Performance Complaint include, but are not limited to:

  • Product or process change without customer approval, if customer approval is required
  • Certified site use of alternative component sources not included in part approval and without customer approval, if required
  • Use of substitute “equivalent” materials without validation and without customer approval, if required
  • Use of substitute manufacturing equipment, without customer approval, if required
  • Continued operation of tooling beyond agreed viable tooling life, without customer tooling approval, if required
  • Consistent cases of site personnel not complying with the agreed Control Plans
  • Elimination of required maintenance activities, without customer approval, if required

Note: each customer can specify the particular processes, requirements and recent time periods to trigger the consideration of issuing a Performance Complaint for not complying with customer-specified processes

Unacceptable Performance Complaint Examples for Process Complaint Concerns:

Examples of issues or concerns that should NOT be filed as a process performance complaint include, but are not limited to:

  • Product or process change without customer approval, in the case where customer approval is not required
  • Certified site use of alternative component sources which were included in initial or subsequent part approval
  • Use of substitute “equivalent” materials already included in initial process and/or product approvals
  • Use of substitute manufacturing equipment, previously approved through an approved substitution process
  • Continued operation of tooling beyond initially agreed viable tooling life but subsequently approved through a customer waiver or exception
  • Use of approved alternate Control Plans under specific conditions
  • Failure to follow a process requirement that was agreed to be the responsibility of another entity, such as a lower tier supplier

Note: these conditions and examples can vary for all customers